Articles

April 2019 – Question of the Month

April 23, 2019 - By Ian Munro, Director, B Bus Sci (IS Hons) M Com (IS)

Question of the Month: How do you implement care and growth if the company’s existing reward system is tightly coupled to results?

Answer: The Legitimate Leadership Model says people should be held accountable for their contribution. Not how hard they tried or how much effort they put in, and not whether the result was achieved or not, but their actual contribution against an agreed standard.

The leader then needs to determine whether the contribution made was on, above, or below the standard; understand why this was the case; and then reward, recognize, censure or discipline appropriately.

In practice, this can be difficult to implement. And in practice, most company rewards systems are actually funded by the results achieved. Rewards are tightly coupled to results and people are promised bonuses on the basis of how much money there is in the bonus pool (i.e. the result).

But the perceived conflict here with the Legitimate Leadership Model is often overstated. This is because in any leadership situation there are seven possibilities: Care; provide the Means; build the Ability; Reward; Recognise; Censure; Discipline.

A misaligned rewards/bonus system is not disabling of the Legitimate Leadership Model – it only actually affects one of the seven possibilities: reward.

If there is no money in the bonus pool for contribution, then get creative – or just type “how to reward without money” into Google.

The organisational fix to this problem is consistency and planning. If you reward for contribution consistently in both good and bad times, you fill the coffers during the good times by not giving money away to people who didn’t contribute, and so you have money in the bank to reward excellent contributions in when the bad times come.

Ian Munro
Wendy Lambourne

June 2024 – Question Of The Month

Wendy Lambourne

Leonie van Tonder

Clear Performance Expectations Enable Employee Success

Leonie van Tonder

Wendy Lambourne

May 2024 – Question Of The Month

Wendy Lambourne

Legitimate Leadership

News: The Origins Of Legitimate Leadership In Action

Legitimate Leadership

Stefaan van den Heever

April 2024 – Question Of The Month

Stefaan van den Heever

Tony Flannigan

Can You Care And Grow People And Have Accountability In A Matrix Organisation?

Tony Flannigan

Wendy Lambourne

The Kind Of Person That People Are Motivated By

Wendy Lambourne

Legitimate Leadership

News: Legitimate Leadership’s New Programme – Safety Leadership Excellence In Practice

Legitimate Leadership

Sean Hagger

March 2024 – Question Of The Month

Sean Hagger

Rachael Cowin

Safety Leadership – The Difference That Makes the Difference

Rachael Cowin