Articles

September 2021 – Question Of The Month

September 27, 2021 - By Wendy Lambourne, Director, MA Industrial and Organisation Psychology, Registered Psychologist with SA Medical & Dental Council

Question:  What about if someone has deliberately chosen not to follow a safe system at work or a work instruction, but he did not mean for something bad to happen? As this is a breach of health and safety regulations, he having deliberately chosen to deviate from the work instruction, is disciplinary action the right response?

Answer: Legitimate Leadership believes that the appropriate leadership action when somebody does not do what he/she should do or does what he/she should not do is to ascertain ‘why’. This is only fair.

There are in fact only six ‘whys’ – and the subsequent leadership action should align with the applicable ‘why’. The medicine, in other words, should match the malady.

The six ‘whys’, and appropriate leadership actions, are:

  1. Lacks the means – provide the means.
  2. Does not know how or why – provide training/coaching.
  3. Is incapable – remove from the role/redesign the work.
  4. Is sloppy/careless – censure/insist on careful.
  5. Wilfully does not do it/is deliberately malevolent – discipline/sanction.
  6. There is a mismatch in what is motivating/required – remove from role/redesign work.

So yes, if as is suggested the person wilfully or deliberately chose not to follow the work instruction, some disciplinary action or sanction is appropriate. If leaders fail to hold people to account for their deliberate malevolence they cannot be surprised if there is a continuation of the deliberate malevolence.

Wendy Lambourne
Wendy Lambourne

July 2022 – Question Of The Month

Wendy Lambourne

Bartleby

Managers Aren’t Heroes But They Deserve More Understanding

Bartleby

Wendy Lambourne

Organisational Change Is Impossible Without People Change

Wendy Lambourne

Wendy Lambourne

June 2022 – Question Of The Month

Wendy Lambourne

Teigue Payne

Legitimate Leadership’s Roots In Workplace Safety

Teigue Payne

Rachael Cowin

Being Methodical About Empowerment

Rachael Cowin

Joolz Lewis

May 2022 – Question Of The Month

Joolz Lewis

Angela Donnelly

Trusting Team Members Results In Positive Asymmetry

Angela Donnelly

Ian Munro

What Should We Hold Our People Accountable For? (Clue: It’s Not Results)

Ian Munro

Sean Hagger

April 2022 – Question Of The Month

Sean Hagger